Forum: TradeBullet and Collective2

New?Last PostPosted By#Subject
3/29/14 (20:18)Huck Williams1update to active forum
2/06/14 (14:11)Francis Gingras1Build 861 is available
12/03/13 (18:50)Francis Gingras4Scaling for futures system
9/09/13 (14:54)Francis Gingras2TB auto sync
6/04/13 (9:59)Francis Gingras2Pending Orders
2/19/13 (22:10)Francis Gingras2TradeBullet and C2 with MB Trading
2/04/13 (15:49)Matthew Klein2Collective doesnot support TradeBullet ????!!!
 
Older subjects >>



Post new message

 
Subject:Rejected order
Posted by:Randy May  New msg
 
Ignore user's posts for week month forever
When:3/10/06 (11:14) 
 
I don't know if this is a TB issue or a C2 issue, but I had an order rejected by TB this morning for the Black Dog system. TB says:

"Order being modified does not match original order (105) (OrderRejected)."

The original BTO order was placed via C2/TB and shows up correctly in the TB Execution window, and in my IB account. But this partial STC order (for 1/3 of the position) was rejected. Any idea what could cause this one?
  
 
Subject:Rejected order
Posted by:TradeBullet Support  New msg
 
Ignore user's posts for week month forever
When:3/10/06 (11:34) 
 

In response to post by Randy May of 3/10/06 (11:14)

I don't know if this is a TB issue or a C2 issue, but I had an order rejected by TB this morning for the Black Dog syste...

See entire

No I don't: that rejection from IB should only be triggered on invalid order change, not on original order submission.

I suggest uninstalling TWS, completely remove the c:/jts folder and reinstall TWS.

Do you happen to have the IB API installed?

Francis
  
 
Subject:Rejected order
Posted by:Randy May  New msg
 
Ignore user's posts for week month forever
When:3/10/06 (11:41) 
 

In response to post by TradeBullet Support of 3/10/06 (11:34)

No I don't: that rejection from IB should only be triggered on invalid order change, not on original order submission. <...

See entire

Francis,
Thanks. I don't have the IB API installed (that I know of anyway ... I just installed TWS 855.5 some time ago and things have been working OK). Before I do this, can you tell me the latest build numbers for TB and TWS that work together so I don't end up with a mismatch there and lose connectivity altogether?
Randy
  
 
Subject:Rejected order
Posted by:TradeBullet Support  New msg
 
Ignore user's posts for week month forever
When:3/10/06 (13:27) 
 

In response to post by Randy May of 3/10/06 (11:41)

Francis,
Thanks. I don't have the IB API installed (that I know of anyway ... I just installed TWS 855.5 some time...

See entire

Randy,

Get them both from the TB web site and you'll always be matched.

TWS 856.5 and TB 202.

Francis
  
 
Subject:Rejected order
Posted by:Randy May  New msg
 
Ignore user's posts for week month forever
When:3/15/06 (11:50) 
 

In response to post by TradeBullet Support of 3/10/06 (13:27)

Randy,

Get them both from the TB web site and you'll always be matched.

TWS 856.5 and TB 202.

Francis

Francis ... I completed this process (new TB and TWS builds, wiped out C:jts completely, etc.) and had the same problem happen again today. Here is a section of my log file (I'm posting this here since I have no way to know if it is a C2 problem or a TB problem, or neither and it's an IB/TWS bug):

2006-03-15 07:05:31:326 (2006-03-15 15:05 UTC) Processing new C2 order: TB Order TB818949 U250606 PLACE SELL 2 ES 06-06 GLOBEX MARKET DAY, TradeBulletId: 19036406, System: The Black Dog Trading System , Signal: 19036406
2006-03-15 07:05:31:513 (2006-03-15 15:05 UTC) TradeBulletID#19036406 Initialized
2006-03-15 07:05:31:545 (2006-03-15 15:05 UTC) Sending TB Order 19036406 U250606 PLACE SELL 2 ES 06-06 GLOBEX MARKET DAY, TradeBulletId: 19036406, System: The Black Dog Trading System , Signal: 19036406 , Source: Collective2
2006-03-15 07:05:32:138 (2006-03-15 15:05 UTC) TradeBulletID#19036406 Pending Submit
2006-03-15 07:05:32:357 (2006-03-15 15:05 UTC) TradeBulletID#19036406 Accepted
2006-03-15 07:05:32:373 (2006-03-15 15:05 UTC) Order Rejected: TB Order 19036406 U250606 SELL 2 ES 06-06 GLOBEX MARKET DAY, TradeBulletId: 19036406, System: The Black Dog Trading System , Signal: 19036406 , Reason: Order being modified does not match original order (105)
2006-03-15 07:05:32:373 (2006-03-15 15:05 UTC) TradeBulletID#19036406 Rejected

I was sitting at the computer and manually exited the trade at a good price, but this is exactly what happened prior to any resets/upgrades. The only similarity to the previous occurence is that the entry trade was for 10 units, which equals 5 units with my 50% scaling. The vendor exited half of the position, which C2 translated as 3 units leaving me long 2 units. The final order (above) appears to be correct for the 2 remaining units so nothing looks obviously wrong, but the order was never placed in my IB account.
  
 
Subject:Rejected order
Posted by:TradeBullet Support  New msg
 
Ignore user's posts for week month forever
When:3/15/06 (16:51) 
 

In response to post by Randy May of 3/15/06 (11:50)

Francis ... I completed this process (new TB and TWS builds, wiped out C:jts completely, etc.) and had the same problem ...

See entire

Hi Randy,

This a TB-TWS issue, not a C2 issue. Two other users have reported this behavior in the past month, and after a few days things went back to normal. I have asked IB to shed light on the issue: why is the order rejected after being accepted, and why does the rejection say it's been modified?

I'll know more when they answer but that may take a little while; unlike TB and C2, IB support is notoriously slow.

Thanks,

Francis
  
Back up to list of subjects