Collective2 rates every trading system creator in its database and assigns a score between 100 and 1000.
In general, a rating above 500 is good. A rating above 700 is excellent.
Collective2 Ratings are recalculated daily based on the entire performance history in our database. The exact formula we use is proprietary, but there are several key variables that go into the Collective2 Rating.
One of the most important factors is the length of time we have been able to observe the performance of the trader.
Another key factor is the amount by which the trader over-performs or under-performs the S&P 500 index.
Finally, the choppiness of the trader's results is taken into account. Certainly a more consistent system creator will be rated more highly than a system creator with erratic results.
Interesting system that produced many nice trades but seems to have entered the self destruction phase. No stops ahead of time which can be a problem also.
Jan 24, 2007 from AutoTrader
Subscribed end of December - system had a very poor performance during the last month, many losers in a row, system has no money management, not recommended !
Jan 23, 2007 from AutoTrader
works very well with some trending markets,and badly in volatyle markets. what you make here you get back there. a good system should perform in all markets. we are not yet there, hopefully we will one time.
Dec 20, 2006 from AutoTrader
Qtips may be needed - looks like the ears are starting to fill with wax... Why do so many promising systems seem to zenith, after you subscribe???
Rebuttal, posted on Dec 27, 2006 by system developer:
Because my system is dependent on a Nasdaq Trend.
Go look at the NDX for the past 2 months. See any trends?
Nov 1, 2006 from AutoTrader
Amazingly profitable system. System doesn't make huge gambles. It plays it conservative, and wins more often than it loses. Highly recommended!
Oct 24, 2006 from AutoTrader
Very realistic and profitable. Usually holds overnight instead of trying to scalp.
System Description
UPDATE: November 14th 2006(I will be eliminating the DOW{YM} future contracts as they are illiquid and I have been asked to reduce the account size needed to trade QTIPS system;Effective Monday November 20th)System will then be structered as follows.. 10 NDX & 10 SPX on system trend signal and 10 RUT added when strength of signal has been confirmed by QTIPS. RUT usually lags(depends on NDX/SPX strength) other indecies and at $100 per point..the risk/reward ratio quadruples. I need a few more days to test it out on paper. This ammendment will add an overall profit potential loss and slightly more risk when replacing YM with SPX. Besides....DOW 30 is not something a system should trade..
Futures Only(Options remain unprogrammable). . 10 contracts maximum with a total of 4 positions RUT/SPX/INDU/NDX 4 full Future positions=strong signal 2 is average.
All trades are processed during market hours 9:30am-4pm Est and with "at Market" orders. NDX/YM are first signals generated and then RUT/SPX secondary to capture the full move in a trend.
Previous systems closed as instruments used did not work nor was there an option for a test system back then as well as knowledge of systems being permanent. 1st system was not structured and 2nd system used options for longer term signals and resulted in a large drawdown and thus closed system. This system is based on the same indicators with better stop loss placements and less risk/reward ratio.
Ideally...I am working on a system that uses the SPX and the NDX only for current expirations for short term trades and longer expirations for longer term trades(1-? months). This will be geared toward the hedge fund industry or high net worth Investors as a way to capture long term trends but at the same time make consistant money on short term trends.
Most systems on collective2 either scalp(no overnights) or hold big contract positions. Q-TIPS uses only 10 contracts per instrument and holds overnight(few scalps) depending on system signal strength.
quisp
- This System Description text was submitted by the creator of this strategy. Collective2 verifies only trading signals and hypothetical trading results. We have not verified that this text above is an accurate system description. Remember there is a substantial risk of loss in trading. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Do not trade with money you cannot afford to lose.
There is a free trial period of 5 days before you are charged.
You may cancel at any time before this (we send you an email at least a day before, to remind you, so there are no surprises.)
Then, after the trial, you will be charged $100 per month. (That is, we will charge you every 30 days - not when the month name on the calendar changes. So it's okay to sign up towards the end of a calendar month. You'll still get a full 30 days.)
- This text was submitted by the creator of this strategy. Collective2 verifies only trading signals and hypothetical trading results. We have not verified the Overview text above. Remember there is a substantial risk of loss in trading. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Do not trade with money you cannot afford to lose.