How we rate trading systems

A message from Collective2, the free Web site that rates trading systems

Do not trust your own mother.

Let me be honest. If my mother called and offered to sell me a trading system with astounding "real life results," I would hang up the phone. You cannot and should not trust a company that publishes its system "results" without independent verification. It's not simply a question of outright fraud -- although a surprising number of trade systems just make up imaginary numbers. There's a more serious problem. 

For every one trading system that eventually turns out to be profitable, there are nine others that lose money. The same company that touts a "miracle" system in magazine ads probably won't tout the other nine systems that it tried, but which lost money.

Lots of companies sell "astounding" trading systems. Here is a way to prevent being, er,  astounded

Collective2 verifies trading systems

Collective2 is a free Web site that monitors trade systems. When a system recommends a trade, we verify how the trade really performs, by monitoring real-time quotes from the exchanges. More important, a company can't simply throw away bad results it doesn't like. Let me show you a typical chart you will find on our Web site.

A chart that compares and ranks various trading systems.

A chart from the Collective2 Web site, which rates trading systems.

How to read the Collective2 charts

First, notice that we monitor all kinds of trading systems: futures, stocks, options, even Forex. The first step is to look for the kind of system that interests you. Next look at the "age" of the system. This is how long the company has agreed to let us monitor their trading system. You should subscribe to trading systems only if you are comfortable with the length of time they have been monitored.

Next look at the right side of the chart. Collective2 encourages trading systems to offer subscribers free trial periods or performance guarantees.

To see examples of this, look at the magnified view to the right. Notice how there are many trading systems on the Collective2 Web site, and many of them offer some kind of free trial period or profit guarantee. And because it is Collective2 which is responsible for measuring profitability - not the system vendor - you know that you will be charged fairly.

How to "subscribe" to a trading system

Once you are interested in a trading system, subscribing is easy. Collective2 -- not the trading system company -- is responsible for keeping track of your subscription information, and for emailing the trades recommended by the system. So you never have to trust a small operator with your credit card or personal information.

After you subscribe, here's what happens. Whenever the trade system makes a new trade recommendation, an email is automatically sent to you - instantly - telling you what to trade, where to set your stop loss, etc. Here's an example of a "trade signal" you might receive:

Our Web site is free

It costs nothing to use our Web site to find a good trading system. (Rather, Collective2 makes money by charging trading system vendors a commission for each subscriber they receive.)

Are you ready to look at the trading systems on the Collective2 Web site?

 
       

Yes, take me to the Collective2 Site